ReallyRated
Maybelline Sky High

Maybelline

Maybelline Sky High

68

ReallyRated Score

1.0K Reddit mentions · 3 subreddits

Trending up

Community sentiment78% positive

Redditors generally praise Maybelline Sky High mascara for its impressive lengthening and volumizing effects, often highlighting its ability to create a natural, fluttery lash look. It is frequently recommended in makeup routines for an everyday yet noticeable lash enhancement. However, some users note occasional issues with flaking or smudging after extended wear.

— Reddit community consensus

$7-15

Check Price on Amazon

We may earn a commission from affiliate links. Learn more

Pros

  • Provides significant length and volume without clumping
  • Buildable formula that creates a natural, fluttery lash effect
  • Affordable and widely accessible
  • Works well with other makeup products and primers
  • Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers

Cons

  • Some reports of flaking or smudging after long wear
  • Can be a bit wet initially, requiring a short drying time
  • May not hold curl as well for users with very stubborn lashes
  • Limited shade options (primarily Black and True Brown)

68

Score / 100

1.0K

Reddit mentions

3

Subreddits

78%

Positive

What Reddit Says

Redditors generally praise Maybelline Sky High mascara for its impressive lengthening and volumizing effects, often highlighting its ability to create a natural, fluttery lash look. It is frequently recommended in makeup routines for an everyday yet noticeable lash enhancement. However, some users note occasional issues with flaking or smudging after extended wear.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Provides significant length and volume without clumping
  • Buildable formula that creates a natural, fluttery lash effect
  • Affordable and widely accessible
  • Works well with other makeup products and primers
  • Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers

Cons

  • Some reports of flaking or smudging after long wear
  • Can be a bit wet initially, requiring a short drying time
  • May not hold curl as well for users with very stubborn lashes
  • Limited shade options (primarily Black and True Brown)

Who Is It For?

Best For

  • Users seeking affordable, everyday mascara with lengthening effects
  • People preferring a natural, fluttery lash look instead of dramatic volume
  • Those with sensitive eyes or contact lenses looking for gentle formulas

Avoid If

  • !You need a mascara with extreme curl retention for stubborn lashes
  • !You are looking for waterproof or highly smudge-proof formulas

You Might Also Like

Urban Decay All Nighter
72
Trending

Urban Decay

Urban Decay All Nighter

Redditors widely praise Urban Decay All Nighter setting spray for its long-lasting hold and ability to keep makeup looking fresh all day. It is frequently recommended as a reliable finishing spray that prevents shine and makeup fading without feeling heavy or sticky.

$30-404.4K mentions
NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer
71
Trending

NARS

NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer

Redditors widely praise the NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer for its smooth, buildable coverage and natural radiant finish that works well for under-eye and blemish coverage. It is frequently recommended in makeup routines for its versatility and flattering texture, though some users note concerns about creasing and price.

$30-354.4K mentions
Armani Luminous Silk
71
Trending

Armani

Armani Luminous Silk

Redditors consistently praise Armani Luminous Silk foundation for its natural, luminous finish and excellent shade range that blends well with skin tones. It is often described as worth the investment due to its flattering appearance in photos and everyday wear. However, some users mention its high price and occasional difficulty finding the perfect shade match.

$60-802.6K mentions
Tarte Shape Tape
71
Trending

Tarte

Tarte Shape Tape

Redditors widely praise Tarte Shape Tape for its full coverage and long-lasting concealing ability, making it a staple in many makeup routines since 2016. It is frequently paired with various foundations and praised for its blendability and high pigmentation, though some users note potential issues with dryness or creasing on certain skin types.

$25-356.2K mentions