ReallyRated
Kirkland olive oil

Kirkland/Costco

Kirkland olive oil

35

ReallyRated Score

104 Reddit mentions · 11 subreddits

Trending up

Community sentiment85% positive

“Redditors generally regard Kirkland olive oil as a high-quality, authentic olive oil that offers excellent taste comparable to more expensive mid-range brands. It is praised for its value, flavor, and authenticity, especially among users seeking genuine Italian olive oil at a great price.”

— Reddit community consensus

$15-25

Check Price on Amazon

We may earn a commission from affiliate links. Learn more

Pros

  • ✓Considered authentic, imported Italian olive oil with verified certification
  • ✓Excellent taste comparable to mid-high range olive oils
  • ✓Great value for the price, often called the best deal in olive oil
  • ✓Preferred by users familiar with traditional olive oil flavors, including those from Mediterranean backgrounds
  • ✓Widely available in large quantities making it convenient for regular use

Cons

  • ✗Some users may prefer smaller bottles for easier handling and freshness
  • ✗Not typically highlighted as a premium or artisanal brand, so may not appeal to niche gourmet buyers
  • ✗Few mentions of packaging issues such as bulk size being less ideal for certain kitchens

35

Score / 100

104

Reddit mentions

11

Subreddits

85%

Positive

What Reddit Says

Redditors generally regard Kirkland olive oil as a high-quality, authentic olive oil that offers excellent taste comparable to more expensive mid-range brands. It is praised for its value, flavor, and authenticity, especially among users seeking genuine Italian olive oil at a great price.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • ✓Considered authentic, imported Italian olive oil with verified certification
  • ✓Excellent taste comparable to mid-high range olive oils
  • ✓Great value for the price, often called the best deal in olive oil
  • ✓Preferred by users familiar with traditional olive oil flavors, including those from Mediterranean backgrounds
  • ✓Widely available in large quantities making it convenient for regular use

Cons

  • ✗Some users may prefer smaller bottles for easier handling and freshness
  • ✗Not typically highlighted as a premium or artisanal brand, so may not appeal to niche gourmet buyers
  • ✗Few mentions of packaging issues such as bulk size being less ideal for certain kitchens

Who Is It For?

Best For

  • →Budget-conscious home cooks seeking authentic Italian olive oil
  • →Users who cook frequently and need a reliable, flavorful olive oil in bulk
  • →People familiar with Mediterranean olive oil taste looking for a good local substitute

Avoid If

  • !Seeking boutique or artisanal olive oils with unique flavor profiles
  • !Prefer small, specialty bottles or organic-only certifications

You Might Also Like

gorilla glue
82
Trending

Gorilla

Gorilla Glue

Redditors widely regard Gorilla Glue as a reliable and versatile adhesive that performs exceptionally well for various household and craft projects. It is praised for its strong bonding capabilities and ease of use, though some users note the need for careful application due to its strong adhesive properties.

$5-151.3K mentions
scotch tape
82
Trending

Scotch

Scotch Tape

Redditors consistently appreciate Scotch tape for its reliable adhesive quality and versatility in everyday tasks, from household fixes to creative uses. However, some users note that cheaper variants or improper application can lead to visible resealing and reduced effectiveness.

$5-152.2K mentions
command strips
79
Trending

3M/Command

Command Strips

Redditors generally find 3M Command Strips effective for damage-free hanging but caution about potential paint removal and occasional failure, especially with knockoffs. They are widely recommended for renters and those avoiding nails, though some users report issues with holding heavier items or damaging walls upon removal.

$10-202.8K mentions
command hooks
78
Trending

3M/Command

Command Hooks

Redditors generally find 3M Command hooks to be a convenient and versatile solution for organizing and hanging items without damaging walls, though opinions vary on their durability and weight capacity. While many appreciate their ease of use and damage-free removal, some users caution against relying on them for heavy or valuable items due to occasional failures.

$10-201.5K mentions