Thorogood
Redditors generally view the Thorogood 1892 boots as a solid, reliable entry-level option with better-than-expected quality and comfort. While not considered on par with premium brands like Red Wing, they are valued for their good price-to-performance ratio and unique styles like the Dodgeville and Indigo Dyed Chromexcel models.
New Balance
Redditors generally view the New Balance 990v5 as a comfortable and stylish sneaker with reliable quality, especially praised for its fit and classic aesthetic. However, sizing inconsistencies and a relatively high price point are common points of discussion.
Salomon
Redditors generally praise the Salomon X Ultra for its versatility, comfort, and reliable performance on varied terrains, especially for hiking and travel. While many users find it suitable for both rugged outdoor use and urban environments, some express concerns about sizing and durability under extreme conditions.
Danner
Reddit users appreciate the Danner Bull Run for its moc toe design, solid construction, and good value, especially when purchased on sale. However, some mention that the boots are better suited for milder weather and that the recraftability cost can be a consideration.
Keen
Redditors generally view the Keen Targhee as a reliable and durable hiking shoe that performs well in wet conditions due to its waterproof features. It is praised for comfort and versatility but some users note that it may not be ideal for technical climbing or very rugged terrain.
Grant Stone
Redditors appreciate the Grant Stone Cap Toe boots for their quality materials and craftsmanship, especially praising unique leather options like Forest Kudu and British Tan Calf. The boots are noted for their versatility across smart casual to semi-formal settings, with many valuing the goodyear welt construction and comfortable fit after break-in.
Puma
Reddit users generally view the Puma RS-X as a stylish and comfortable sneaker with good cushioning suitable for casual wear and light running. The shoe's bold design and various colorways receive positive remarks, though some users note it may not be ideal for more serious athletic activities.
Oboz
Redditors generally appreciate the Oboz Sawtooth for its comfort and support, especially in the mid-height version, but some users find the low version less suitable for long walking days. While many praise its comfort, a few mention fit issues and discomfort after limited use. Overall, it is regarded as a reliable hiking shoe with some caveats regarding fit and long-term wear.
Grant Stone
Redditors generally praise the Grant Stone Edward boots for their high-quality Horween shell cordovan leather and solid Goodyear welt construction, highlighting durability and premium materials. Some users note minor delays in delivery and a break-in period but overall regard them as reliable, well-crafted boots suitable for everyday wear.
Oboz
Redditors generally praise the Oboz Bridger for its durability, warmth, and supportive structure, especially for cold weather and rugged terrain. While it initially feels stiff, it breaks in well and performs strongly in waterproof and insulated hiking boots categories.